By Joseph T. Ellington Jr. · Virginia Licensed Residential Real Estate Appraiser
Last updated

Why I save our conversation for the end
The mistake I see most often on appraisal day is following me from room to room and talking me through the house while I’m taking notes. I want to hear what you’ve done. Give me a chance to finish the walkthrough first so I can give you my full attention.
In a single room I might have 15 to 20 things to note, along with the photos I need to take. I’m looking at the flooring, the materials, the finishes and their condition. If we get into a conversation about the kitchen while I’m still standing in a bedroom, it’s easy to miss something. That’s usually when I ask if we can go over the updates at the end. You’re welcome to walk with me. It’s the running conversation that breaks my concentration.

- Cabinets. I look at the finish and check for visible wear.
- Countertops. I note the material and its condition.
- Sink. A sink can be installed before the plumbing is connected. I check whether it’s usable.
- Flooring. I identify the floor covering and record its condition.
Kitchen photo from my September 2024 appraisal files. It illustrates what I look for during a visit. The four-condo sales comparison below is a separate example.
Does a messy house affect an appraisal?
When somebody opens the door and says, “Sorry about the mess,” I usually tell them, “Oh, don’t worry about it.” I’m there to see what the house is made of and what condition it’s in. If I can see the same floors, kitchen and bathrooms, I can reach the same opinion of value whether you’ve moved out, you’re still living there or you’re halfway through packing.
One room full of moving boxes is a familiar sight. The limit is when I can’t tell what I’m looking at. At one house, rugs covered the floors and belongings were piled on top of the rugs. There was a path through, but I couldn’t even tell whether the floor underneath was hardwood or carpet. I stopped and told the client I couldn’t complete the interior observation. I can count situations like that on one hand in more than 20 years.
At a different property, fleas jumped onto my socks as soon as I went inside. I left and told the client I wouldn’t be returning. Those are the kinds of situations I mean when I talk about access. A laundry basket on the couch is a long way from either one.
What if the kitchen or bathroom is halfway through a remodel?
The question I ask is whether the room works that day. A kitchen can have new cabinets and a sink sitting in the countertop, but if the sink’s plumbing hasn’t been connected, you still can’t use it to wash a dish. A bathroom with the toilet removed is another example. If I walk in during that stage, tell me exactly what remains to be done.
On a new house under construction, I may have the plans and specifications to show what the builder is going to finish. If the assignment calls for a value subject to completion, I can use those details and state the assumption that the specified work is complete. On assignments where I’m asked to verify completion, I typically return to see the finished work.
If the client needs the property’s value in its present condition and the assignment allows it, an estimate of the cost to finish can help my analysis. The effect on market value still has to be supported by how buyers respond. The report needs to be clear about which condition the value describes. Read more about as-is and as-completed appraisals.
Why can’t I price a kitchen update during the walkthrough?
When an owner asks, “How much is this kitchen hurting my value?” my answer at the house is, “I don’t really know.” I can see the cabinets, counters and flooring while I’m standing there. To put a dollar figure on the difference, I have to see what buyers paid for comparable homes.
Early in my career I sometimes picked sales before the visit. Then I’d see the interior and have to start my search again. These days, I look at the house first. If you’ve updated the kitchen, tell me what you changed and roughly when. That gives me something specific to compare when I get back to my desk.
On one Hampton Roads assignment, I compared four condos that were the exact same model. Two had updated kitchens and two had dated kitchens. The kitchen was the only update that distinguished the two groups in my condition analysis. The units with updated kitchens sold for $25,000 more, so I used that difference to support the condition adjustment on that appraisal.
Sale-price difference relative to the two condos with dated kitchens
All four sales were the exact same condo model. The $25,000 is the observed sale-price difference that supported my condition adjustment on this assignment.
That’s why I wait until I’ve done the research to answer that question. For your kitchen, I’d need the sales that compete with your home. See the other factors that can affect an appraised value.
What I ask you to write down
While I’m taking notes, put together a short list of updates and the approximate year of each one. When we sit down, I start with the kitchen, then the bathrooms. Which bathroom did you update? What did you actually change? After that I ask about flooring, the roof, heating and cooling, and exterior work such as replacement siding. Then I ask, “What else has been updated?”
This is where you can tell me something I couldn’t see. Maybe you had the crawl space encapsulated. Maybe the heating unit in the attic was replaced. Tell me what work was done and about when. If all you remember is the year, that’s useful. New light switches and recessed lights might catch a buyer’s eye, but I generally learn more about the house from knowing which systems you replaced and the extent of the work.
Give me room to make my observations, then give me that list. I can finish the visit knowing what I saw, what you told me and what I still need to check. Here are the records that can help.
Sources
Joseph T. Ellington Jr. is a Virginia Licensed Residential Real Estate Appraiser and the owner of Capital Valuations in Virginia Beach. He has more than 20 years of appraisal experience in Hampton Roads. About Joe · Request a private appraisal