By Joseph T. Ellington Jr. – Licensed Residential Appraiser, Capital Valuations. Updated November 2026.
What “reconciled value” means in an appraisal
An appraisal may show several adjusted comparable-sale indications but ends with one supported opinion of value. Reconciliation is the appraiser’s explanation of how the evidence was weighed. It is not a button that “finds” extra equity, and the final figure does not have to equal the arithmetic average of adjusted sales.

Follow the evidence, not a formula
When using the sales comparison approach, an appraiser studies sales that compete with the subject and makes supported adjustments for material differences. Data quality, similarity, location, timing, and adjustment size all affect how persuasive a sale is. A more recent sale is not automatically the best indicator, and one with fewer total adjustments may still have an important difference. The Appraisal Institute describes the sales comparison, cost, and income approaches; the applicable approaches depend on the property and assignment.
How I decide which comparable deserves the most weight
I start with the home that is most similar to the subject property—the home I am appraising. I look at how close the sale is, how recently it sold, and how much adjustment it needs. Typically, a recent, nearby sale with strong overall similarity and fewer gross adjustments is a persuasive indicator.
Gross adjustments show the total amount of adjustment without letting positive and negative amounts cancel each other out. They help me see how much the comparison depends on adjustments. I consider that alongside the property’s similarities and the reliability of the information.
Like a lot of appraisal questions, the answer is: it depends. One sale might be closer, another might be more recent, and another might be a better match for the house itself. I use professional judgment to decide which evidence is most persuasive for that assignment. The closest sale or the smallest adjustment total does not automatically settle the question.
For Fannie Mae assignments, its adjustment guidance says adjustment amounts alone cannot determine a comparable’s acceptability and calls for an explanation of which sales received the most weight. Its comparable-sale guidance also recognizes that an older sale can be the better comparison.
A worked example: weighing three adjusted indications
This is a hypothetical illustration of the reasoning above, not an actual Capital Valuations assignment. The values, sale timing, and property descriptions are illustrative.
Assume the subject is a house in an established neighborhood and the sales below are verified, competitive alternatives. Their adjusted indications already reflect supported adjustments for relevant differences, including market conditions where warranted.
| Sale | Adjusted indication | Reason for its relative weight |
|---|---|---|
| Comparable A | $500,000 | Same neighborhood; similar size, layout, and condition; sold two months ago. It requires the least gross adjustment and receives the most weight in this example. |
| Comparable B | $510,000 | Same neighborhood and sold one month ago, but size and condition differences require more adjustment. It provides support, with less weight than A despite being more recent. |
| Comparable C | $495,000 | Similar layout and condition in a competing neighborhood; sold eight months ago. Its location and timing require more analysis, so it receives less weight in this example. |
The adjusted indications range from $495,000 to $510,000. Their arithmetic average is about $501,667. If the underlying data and adjustment support make A the most reliable indicator, a sales-comparison conclusion of $500,000 could be reasonable. B and C still help establish the supported range.
The explanation matters: A receives the most weight because its overall similarity, location, timing, and adjustment support make it the strongest comparison in this hypothetical set. That conclusion does not come from a fixed percentage assigned to each sale. Different evidence could make B, C, or a different point within the range more persuasive. The final appraisal conclusion also considers any other applicable approaches to value.

Why simply averaging adjusted prices can fail
Three sales may not be equally reliable. One may require fewer adjustments, another may show an unusual sale circumstance, and a third may represent a different buyer segment. A reasoned reconciliation discusses those differences and the limits of the data. Do not infer that a sale price, asking price, tax assessment or automated online estimate should be the final answer by itself.

What homeowners can check in a report
- Is the subject described correctly, including relevant area, condition and site features?
- Do the comparable sales resemble the property’s likely alternatives for buyers?
- Are material differences and market timing explained?
- Does the conclusion make sense in light of the evidence and any stated limitations?
If you discover a specific mistake in a lender-ordered appraisal, use the lender’s reconsideration of value process. A different opinion alone does not prove an error. Read our separate explanations of comparable selection and size adjustments for the underlying analysis.

Can a private appraisal settle a loan decision?
A private appraisal can inform a seller, owner, or other intended user under its stated scope. A mortgage lender may require its own appraisal or valuation process and decides the loan. For a private assignment in Virginia Beach or nearby Hampton Roads communities, contact Capital Valuations with the property and intended use.
