Skip to main content

Capital Valuations VA

By · Virginia Licensed Residential Appraiser

An extraordinary assumption means I have a reasonable basis to treat an uncertain fact as true on the date of value. If I’m wrong, that could change my opinion of value. At one house, the whole question was whether a gutter repair had stopped the leak.

Ceiling opening marked A and discolored, peeling drywall marked B.

July 2024 / Archive

Reading the ceiling

A · Opening in the drywall
A gap exposes part of the ceiling cavity.
B · Damaged finish
The surface is peeling and discolored.
Illustrative photo from my appraisal archive. The ceiling finish is visible here. The photo alone cannot establish whether a leak was active.

What I could see through the ceiling opening

At one house I saw discoloration and a hole in the ceiling drywall. I asked the homeowner what happened. They told me the gutter had been leaking into the corner of the house and it created a little pool. Then the water started leaking through the ceiling. They got it fixed, but they never fixed the ceiling drywall.

I’m not a professional in roofing or drywall. So in that situation I would just notate what I see. I did not see any leaking on the floor or any evidence of water damage there. I looked up in the hole that was still there. In the part I could see, there was no rotting wood, and you could see the wood had been replaced.

That fit the homeowner’s explanation. The limit was what I could see through that opening. If the leak only showed up in the rain, I could miss it on a dry day.

What the assumption meant for the appraisal

Observed
No leaking on the floor. Through the opening, I could see the wood had been replaced.
Reported
The homeowner said they got it fixed, but they never fixed the ceiling drywall.
Assumed
The leak is fixed and it’s only cosmetic damage. The drywall still needs repair.

Usually when I use an extraordinary assumption, it’s notated in the report and it explains exactly what it is and what it’s applied to. Here I’d make an extraordinary assumption that the leak is fixed. The only thing left is the drywall, according to the homeowner.

I would say the appraiser doesn’t see any evidence of leaking during the time of inspection. That sentence tells you what I observed. The value depended on one more thing. I assumed the source of the leak had been repaired and only the ceiling finish still needed work. Using that assumption might have affected my conclusion.

I might make an adjustment for that drywall or use it as a condition adjustment, depending on the comparable sales. If that assumption were to be incorrect, a buyer could face more than the cost of patching drywall. The source of the water would still need attention.

What if I had seen water coming through?

If it was leaking, then I wouldn’t make an extraordinary assumption that the leak is fixed. I would call it out. I’ve had people ask me to assume away a problem I could see. Once I know that it’s messed up, I can’t make an extraordinary assumption that the work has been done.

A hypothetical condition is something that you know is not true, and you’re doing it hypothetically as if it were. Take that same ceiling. Valuing the house as if the leak had been repaired on a date when I could see it dripping would require a sound reason, a credible analysis and disclosure of that premise and its possible effect.

What to send if you learn more

If homeowners have more evidence of anything, they can always send it to me. A roofer’s written findings or a dated photo of the ceiling during a storm can help. The date matters. A drip photographed the week before my visit raises a different question from one that first appeared after a later storm.

About the author

Joseph T. Ellington Jr., Virginia Licensed Residential Appraiser and owner of Capital Valuations in Virginia Beach, has 20+ years of appraisal experience and provides private appraisals across Hampton Roads.

Related reading · As-is and as-completed appraisals for a planned renovation

I provided the inspection example and reviewed the final article. AI assisted with editing and organizing my dictation.

Sources